Everyday Money Habits · Classroom packet
The match is part of your pay.
One idea sits at the very top of every saving decision: an employer 401(k) match is part of your pay — money your company adds alongside yours, but only if you opt in. This packet walks a group through spotting it, sizing it, and capturing it, in a single sitting. Read it, decode three offers together, talk it through, and everyone leaves with one move.
Lead a group through spotting and capturing an employer match — decode what each offer is really worth, see what it grows to, and name one move each.
You're running a class, small group, or kitchen-table session and want a no-prep handout on why the employer match comes first.
For the leader
Anyone can run this — a teacher, a parent at the kitchen table, a small-group or mentorship leader — for two people or a full room. Four beats:
- Open with the question — don't name the idea yet; let the room argue it first, then reveal the sentence.
- Decode the three offers together. Two of them hand you the same free money for different effort — that's the point.
- Reveal what ten years of one captured match grows to.
- Before you close, everyone names one move out loud.
- 0–4 Open with the question; then name the idea.
- 4–14 Decode the three offers — fill them in together.
- 14–20 What it grows to — guess, then reveal.
- 20–27 Talk it through.
- 27–30 One move each.
"Most people think a 401(k) match is a perk. Today we work out what it is really worth — and whether turning it down is ever the smart move — before we settle what it actually is."
1 · The whole idea, in one sentence
Your job offers to add 50 cents for every dollar you put into your retirement plan, up to a limit. If you put in nothing, what is that offer worth to you — and is turning it down ever the smart move?
An employer match is part of your pay — you just have to opt in to receive it.
A 401(k) is a retirement account you fund through work, straight from your paycheck. A match means your employer adds money alongside what you put in — often 50¢ or a full dollar for every dollar you contribute, up to a ceiling (usually a few percent of your salary). Contribute up to that ceiling and you capture the whole match; contribute nothing and you leave all of it behind. It isn't a bonus or a gift — it's a second number on your offer letter that you only collect if you say yes.
2 · Decode the offer
Every match offer tells you two things: how much your employer adds per dollar, and the ceiling — the most of your pay they'll match. Here are three, all on a $60,000 salary. For each, work out what you'd have to put in to capture the whole match, and how much free money the employer would add. Fill them in together.
Hint: the contribution that captures the whole match is the ceiling percent of $60,000. Watch what happens to the free money across the three — two of them add up to the same amount.
3 · What one captured match grows to
Take the first offer — a $1,800 match every year. The match doesn't sit in cash; it's invested — in the funds inside the plan, often a target-date fund — alongside your own money. Capture it for ten years, earning 7% a year, and the match alone — not counting a cent of your own contributions — grows to a number most people guess far too low. Write a guess before anyone turns to the answers.
The 7% here is an after-inflation estimate of long-run stock-market returns, used to keep the example concrete; your real number will vary. The point isn't the exact figure — it's that you didn't work a single extra hour for it.
4 · Talk it through
- Two of the three offers hand you the exact same $1,800 — but one asks you to put in twice as much of your own pay. Which would you take, and why?
- Some plans 'vest' the match over a few years — you don't fully own it until you've stayed, and if you leave too early the employer takes that part back. How might that change your plans, or not?
- The most common reason people skip the match is debt. The lesson says capture the match first anyway — why might an instant 50–100% return on what you put in beat a year of chipping away at a loan?
- If you don't have a job with a 401(k) yet, what's the one question you'll ask about benefits before you accept an offer?
A case to argue
A friend just started a job and got auto-enrolled in the 401(k) at 3%. "I didn't really choose it — I just clicked through the forms on day one," they say. "Sounds like I'm all set, right?" Their employer matches up to 6% of pay.
What would you tell this person?
5 · One move
The match rewards one thing: opting in up to the ceiling. If you already have a plan, that's concrete — log into your benefits portal, find the field called "contribution rate" or "deferral percentage," and raise it to the match ceiling. It's a couple of clicks, and it's the first step in a longer sequence called the order of operations, with the match at the very top. Go around the group; each person names one move and a date — raise a contribution to the match ceiling, or (if there's no job with a match yet) the benefits question to ask before accepting an offer.
No job with a match yet? Your move is the question — "Does this job match my 401(k), and up to what percent?" — asked before you accept an offer, so the match is part of the deal from day one.
Answer key · for the leader
Hold this page back until everyone has worked the offers and written a guess — the gap between a guess and the real number is where the lesson lands.
- 50¢ for every $1, up to 6% of pay$3,600 in → $1,800 free
- $1 for every $1, up to 3% of pay$1,800 in → $1,800 free
- $1 for every $1, up to 5% of pay$3,000 in → $3,000 free
The close call: the first two offers both add $1,800 of free money — but the second asks you to put in only 3% of your pay, not 6%. For a cash-strapped early-career saver, that second offer is the easier capture — the same free money for half the contribution; the first offer's higher ceiling only wins if you can comfortably save the extra. There's no wrong answer — the win is capturing the whole match in every case.
The $1,800 match, captured each year for 10 years and invested at 7%, grows to about $25,963 — and that's just the match. Your own contributions add roughly $51,925 on top. (Same figures the lesson's calculator shows, compounded monthly; at a more conservative rate the numbers shrink but the free-money lead holds.)
Unvested employer match is forfeited if you leave before the plan's vesting schedule finishes — but your own contributions are always 100% yours. Many plans vest the match immediately; others take three to five years. It's a reason to know your schedule, not a reason to skip the match.
Any answer that names the match as pay you have to opt into works — e.g. "It's money my employer already set aside for me, and I only get it if I put in my share."
A strong answer starts with the good news — auto-enrollment did the hardest part, it started them saving — then names the gap: 3% is a floor the plan picked, not the finish line. If the employer matches up to 6% and they're in at 3%, they're collecting only half the match — the other 3% of pay is free money never deposited, every single check. The move is one log-in: raise the contribution to at least the 6% match ceiling, and switch on auto-escalation ("automatic increase") if the plan offers it, so the rate climbs on its own. Leave the Roth setting alone unless they're a high earner expecting a lower bracket later. Drawn from the "HR signed me up for a Roth 401(k) at 3%" Moment (M5) on the site.
Based on the lesson on the employer match.
michaelwestfinancials.com · © 2026 Michael West Financials · Education, not financial advice · Last reviewed June 2026