Everyday Money Habits · Classroom packet
Where the next dollar goes.
Once the framework, the emergency fund, the match, and a start date are settled, only one question is left: of the 401(k) (your employer's retirement plan), the Roth IRA (a retirement account you open yourself), the HSA, the brokerage, the 529, and any leftover debt — where does the next dollar go? This packet walks a group through the answer in one sitting: the order isn't a preference, it's a return calculation. Read it, rank the moves together, find each person's spot on the map, and everyone leaves with one move.
Lead a group through the order the buckets get funded — rank the five moves by return, find each person's first unchecked box, and name one move each.
You're running a class, small group, or kitchen-table session and want a no-prep handout on where the next dollar should go.
For the leader
Anyone can run this — a teacher, a parent at the kitchen table, a small-group or mentorship leader — for two people or a full room. Four beats:
- Open with the question — don't name the idea yet; let the room argue it first, then reveal the sentence.
- Rank the five moves together — number them 1–5 by which dollar works hardest. The order is the lesson.
- Everyone ticks the personal check; the first unchecked box is their next dollar.
- Before you close, everyone names one move — the first unchecked box — and a date.
- 0–4 Open with the question; then name the idea.
- 4–13 Rank the five moves — guess first, then reveal.
- 13–20 Find your spot — tick the personal check.
- 20–27 Talk it through.
- 27–30 One move each.
"For most of the year the money question is how much can I save? Today we answer the one that comes after it — where does it go next? — and whether that even has a right order, or just comes down to taste."
A sharp group will notice the personal check leads with a little deductible cash, while the ranking puts the match at #1. Both are right — the answer key has the one-line reconciliation; have it in hand before you reveal.
1 · The whole idea, in one sentence
You have $200 left over this month. It could go to debt, to savings, or to investing — all reasonable. Is there a right order to fund them in, or is it just personal taste? What would decide it?
Your next dollar goes to the lowest unfunded step. After any major life change, walk the list again from the top.
There's a map already drawn. Money Guy's Financial Order of Operations and Dave Ramsey's Baby Steps take different paths — Ramsey clears almost all debt before investing; Money Guy captures the employer match first, then turns to debt. But they agree on the shape: build a buffer and clear high-cost debt before you reach for full investing. The detailed map is nine steps; the practical one is five buckets, filled in order. The reason the order holds is the next section.
2 · Put the moves in order
Here are five things you can do with a spare dollar, in no particular order. As a group, number them 1 to 5 — 1 for the dollar that works hardest, 5 for the one that works least. Don't overthink it; put down your best guess, then we'll reveal the returns and see how close the room got. The order you land on is the order of operations.
One hint, since it's the surprise every time: paying off a credit card isn't "spending" — wiping out a 22% interest rate is identical, in dollars, to earning 22%, guaranteed.
3 · Find your spot
The map is only useful applied. Tick what's already true for you. The first unchecked box, reading top to bottom, is where your next dollar belongs — that's the whole tool. Most people land on box two, three, or four; that's the working part of the order.
- I have cash to cover my biggest insurance deductible (what I pay out of pocket before insurance covers the rest).
- I'm getting the full employer 401(k) match.
- I've paid off (or have a written plan for) any debt charging me about 7% or more.
- I have 3–6 months of essential expenses saved up.
- I'm putting money into a Roth IRA and investing the cash inside it.
- I'm funding and investing my HSA — only if my health plan is a high-deductible one.
- I'm putting in up to the yearly 401(k) limit.
The order doesn't move even if you skipped a step early — a missed match doesn't make a 529 the right next dollar. Find the first gap, fill that one. One catch worth saying aloud: opening a Roth IRA and depositing cash isn't the whole move — you also have to pick an investment inside it (usually a low-cost index fund — one fund that holds a sliver of hundreds of companies at once), or the money just sits there as cash.
4 · Talk it through
- Someone says, "I'd rather put money in the stock market than pay off my credit card — the market grows." What's the flaw in that order?
- A safety net earns maybe 1–5% on the cash. Investing earns more over time. Why does the safety net still get funded first?
- Which life events should send you back to the top of the list — to walk it again from the start?
- Where are you in the order right now, and what is the very next box?
A case to argue
A friend is about to get a $15,000 bonus after tax. "Part of me wants to be responsible with it," they say, "and part of me has already spent it three times. Where's it actually supposed to go?"
What would you tell this person?
5 · One move, this week
The lesson's outcome is a single line: your next dollar belongs in X. Do that one thing this week — don't try to fix three; the order is a sequence, not a checklist of parallel projects. For most people the move is quick: raise your 401(k) contribution to at least the percent your employer will match (find the number in your benefits portal, or call HR), open a Roth IRA at a low-cost provider like Fidelity, Vanguard, or Schwab and schedule the first transfer, or add one extra payment to the highest-rate debt. Go around the group; each person names their first unchecked box and a date.
Answer key · for the leader
Keep this page back, or hand it out after the ranking. The point isn't a perfect score — it's the surprise that the order falls right out of the returns, with one deliberate exception.
- Get the full employer match. For every dollar you put in, your employer adds fifty cents to a dollar more — a 50–100% return the day you sign up, guaranteed, instant, and bigger than anything else on the list.
- Build the cash safety net. Two jobs in one: wiping out a 22% credit card is the same, in dollars, as earning 22% risk-free; and the buffer means a bad month doesn't force you to sell investments at the bottom. (The cash earns only 1–5% on its own — it still ranks above market investing because its job is protecting the rest, not earning a return itself.)
- Max a Roth IRA and fund an HSA. Tax-free growth on the market's long-run 4–10%.
- Put more into the 401(k). Same market return, more of it sheltered — up to the yearly limit.
- Everything else. Brokerage, 529, extra mortgage payments, more giving. Real and worthwhile — just last, because the next dollar works a little less hard here.
By pure return, cash savings (1–5%) would sit last — below investing. It outranks investing anyway because its job is different: it buys the buffer that lets you stay invested through a bad year instead of selling at the bottom to cover a surprise bill. Match towers, high-interest debt is identical to earning that rate, and the market comes after both — but the safety net is sorted by what it does, not what it yields.
A sharp group will notice the five-step ranking leads with the match, while the personal check's first box is a little deductible cash. Both are right: the detailed list pulls one slice of the safety net — a small starter cushion, cash for your biggest deductible — out ahead of the match, so you aren't locking every dollar in a 401(k) you can't easily reach. Same order, finer grain: starter cushion → match → kill high-interest debt → full reserve → Roth and HSA → more 401(k) → everything else.
Any answer that names the rule as "fill the highest-return step you haven't filled yet" works — e.g. "My next dollar goes to the first thing on the list I haven't done, starting from the top."
A strong answer treats the windfall as a big next dollar, not a special event: it sorts down the same order — clear high-interest debt, top up the emergency fund, fill this year's tax-advantaged room. Two moves make it work. First, park the whole amount in a separate high-yield savings account the day it clears and decide nothing for thirty days — a windfall isn't an emergency, and "disappearing into checking" is the real risk. Second, mind the annual caps: a lump can't all go into a Roth at once, so the overflow waits for January or goes to a taxable account. The expensive mistake isn't the wrong bucket — it's no bucket at all. Drawn from the "I'm getting a $15K bonus, inheritance, or tax refund" Moment (M7) on the site.
Based on the Where the next dollar goes lesson.
michaelwestfinancials.com · © 2026 Michael West Financials · Education, not financial advice · Last reviewed June 2026