Everyday Money Habits · Classroom packet
Spotting the scam.
Scam advice usually arrives as a list of things to fear: this scam, that scam, the new one from last week. This packet does something steadier — it shows a group the handful of moves underneath all of them. Nearly every scam, whatever costume it wears, runs on the same two moves and is undone by the same one free habit. Sort the messages together, rank the ways to pay a stranger, find each person’s next defense to set, and everyone leaves with one move — calm, not scared.
Lead a group through spotting scams by their two tells, choosing safer ways to pay a stranger, and setting the two free defenses — a credit freeze and the call-back-on-a-number-you-find habit — and name one move each.
You're running a class, small group, or kitchen-table session for new adults and want a no-prep handout on spotting scams and setting up the free defenses before one lands.
For the leader
Anyone can run this — a teacher, a small-group or mentorship leader, a parent at the kitchen table — for two people or a full room. No math background needed. The whole packet turns on one test the group learns to apply: would I act on this if it hadn’t contacted me first? Four beats:
- Open with the question — don’t name the idea yet; let the room argue what they’d do, then reveal the sentence.
- Sort the messages — mark the tell each one shows; the reveal is that the tells are a short list, not a list of scam types.
- Rank the ways to pay a stranger — the reveal is which payments you can claw back and which are just gone.
- Before you close, everyone names one defense to set — the freeze, the call-back rule, a person to check with — and a date.
- 0–4 Open with the question; then name the idea.
- 4–12 Name the tells — mark the messages, then reveal.
- 12–18 Rank the ways to pay — then reveal.
- 18–23 Find your spot — tick the personal check.
- 23–27 Talk it through.
- 27–30 One move each.
"We’re going to look at how scams are built — the text that says your account’s locked, the call from ‘the bank,’ the too-good job. Not to make anyone paranoid, but to see the handful of moves underneath them, so they’re easier to spot than to fall for."
Expect someone to say "I’d never fall for that." Gently resist it — the good ones are built to catch careful people on a busy day, which is exactly why it helps to know the moves. And someone in the room may have already been hit.
If someone shares that they’ve already sent money or handed over info, say plainly — once, out loud — that this happens to careful people and it’s engineered to. Then point them to the recovery steps in the answer key, or to one-on-one help afterward. Don’t work their specific loss in front of the group; the session is about the moves, not anyone’s worst day.
Same session, three changes for a full room, plus one for this session:
- It’s 25–30 students, not a small group. Swap the round-robin close for think-pair-share — everyone writes, pairs trade for a minute, you take four or five out loud.
- A class period runs past thirty minutes. Spend the extra time on the optional case — it’s the best discussion of the hour, not a throwaway.
- Most have no bank account or card of their own yet. Reframe the closing one-move step as "the week you set up your first account…" — a dated intention (place the freeze, set the call-back rule), not homework they can’t do.
- These are landing in their phones right now. The fake-job, the "package on hold," and the apartment-deposit scams hit students hardest — ask the room to read out a suspicious text they got this week and run it through the two tells live.
1 · The whole idea, in one sentence
A text lands: "FRAUD ALERT — did you just spend $499 at Best Buy? Reply NO to cancel." You didn’t spend it, and your heart’s already going. Do you reply NO — and if you don’t, what do you do instead?
Scams run on two moves — a rush, and a push to send money or hand over what you can’t take back. One free habit stops most of them: never act on the message that reached you; call back on a number you find yourself.
Here’s the whole session. Falling for a scam isn’t a sign you’re gullible — the good ones are engineered to catch sharp, busy people. But they’re not endless: nearly every one runs on the same two moves, and the same one habit defuses almost all of them. So the test for anything that reaches you — a text, a call, a DM — is simple: would I act on this if it hadn’t contacted me first? If the answer is no, you don’t argue with the message; you reach the company your own way. The next few minutes practice spotting the moves, then setting the defenses.
2 · Name the tells
Almost every scam runs on one or both of just two moves. Read them once as a group — then, for each message below, write the tell(s) it shows in the box: U, P, both, or OK if it has neither. Not everything that looks alarming is a scam; part of the skill is telling a real message from a fake one.
- A rush — it presses you to act now — a locked account, a deadline, a warrant, a deal about to vanish. Real messages can be urgent too, so a rush alone isn’t proof — but a scam almost always has one.
- A push — it wants you to send money a way you can’t undo (gift card, wire, crypto, payment app) or hand over info (a password, a login code, your card number) right now, through the message itself. This is the tell that gives it away.
One hint, since it’s the surprise every time: the deciding tell is P. Lots of real messages carry a rush — a bank, a delivery, a deadline. What a real institution won’t do is need you to pay a stranger or read back a code through the message itself.
3 · Which way to pay a stranger
Say you have to pay someone you don’t already know — a deposit, a marketplace seller, a service. Here are five ways to do it. As a group, number them 1 to 5: 1 for the safest if it turns out to be a scam, 5 for the most dangerous. The question isn’t which is easiest — it’s which money you could get back.
One hint: the real line isn’t between the five — it’s between one of them and the other four. Think about which payment you could pick up the phone and reverse.
4 · Find your spot
Now make it personal. Tick what’s already true for you. The first unchecked box, reading top to bottom, is the defense worth setting next — none of them cost a thing.
- When a call, text, or email presses me to act now, I stop and reach the company myself — using the number on my card or an app I already have, never a link or number from the message.
- I have a credit freeze in place at all three bureaus — it’s free, it doesn’t touch my credit score, and it blocks anyone from opening new credit in my name.
- When I pay someone I don’t already know and trust, I use a credit card — not a gift card, wire, or payment app, because only the card charge can be reversed if it’s a scam.
- I never read back a login code, passcode, or card number to someone who contacted me — a real bank or company never asks for that.
- I know that if I’m ever hit, IdentityTheft.gov walks me through recovery step by step — and that this happens to careful people, not just careless ones.
The whole defense fits in one sentence you can say out loud, even to someone who sounds official: "I’m going to hang up and call you back on the number on my card — that’s not me doubting you, it’s just what I do for everyone."
5 · Talk it through
- A real text from your bank and a fake one can look almost identical. If you can’t always tell them apart from the message, what’s the one rule that keeps you safe either way?
- Scams count on you being too embarrassed to ask or too rushed to check. Who is the one person you’d text “does this look real to you?” before you act — and would you do it?
- Think of the most convincing scam attempt you’ve seen — a text, a call, a DM. Which of the two tells did it use, and what almost made it work?
A case to argue
Your friend gets a call — the caller ID even shows their bank’s name. "We’ve spotted fraud on your account. To keep your money safe, we’ll help you move it into a new secure account right now." The caller is calm, knows the last four digits of the card, and is walking your friend through the transfer step by step. It feels like the bank is on their side.
What’s actually happening here — and what would you tell your friend to do?
6 · One move, this week
The outcome is a single line: the defense I’ll set is X. Do that one thing this week — place the free credit freeze at all three bureaus, save your bank’s real number in your phone so a fake one can’t rush you, or tell one person "text me before you send money to anyone new." Go around the group; each person names their move and a date.
Answer key · for the leader
Keep this page back, or hand it out after the sort. The point isn’t a perfect score — it’s that the moves are a short list, they repeat under every costume, and one free habit answers nearly all of them.
- U + P — Scam. A tiny fee is the bait; the real prize is your card number on the linked page. No carrier texts a pay-a-fee link out of the blue.
- U + P — Scam. The IRS never calls to demand immediate payment, never takes gift cards, and never threatens arrest over the phone. Urgency + an untraceable payment is the whole scam.
- U — Probably real — but verify your own way. A real fraud alert asks a yes/no and stops there — no money, no codes, so the deciding tell (P) is missing. It could still be faked, so don’t reply; open your bank’s app or call the number on your card. The rule works either way.
- U + P — Scam. The check is fake and bounces days later; the $400 you wired is real and gone. A job that pays you, then asks you to send money back, is always a scam.
- U + P — Scam. Below-market + can’t-show-it + pay-by-Zelle-now is the rental scam. A Zelle payment is like cash — once it’s sent to hold a place that isn’t theirs, it’s gone.
- OK — Legit. No pressure, no push for money or info — nothing to act on but a normal reply. Not everything urgent-looking is a scam; this is the baseline the others break from.
Under six different costumes — a text, a call, a job, a listing, a reminder — there are only two moves: a rush and a push. The deciding one is the push: a real bank or agency can be urgent, but it never needs you to pay a stranger or read back a code through the message that reached you. That’s why the one habit — reach them your own way — works even when you can’t tell a real message from a fake one.
Safest to most dangerous: 1. Credit card — the one payment reversible by law; if it’s a scam you dispute the charge and you’re not out the money while it’s sorted. Then 2. Debit card — some protection, but it’s your own cash that’s gone while you fight to get it back. Then, effectively tied at the bottom, 3–5. Wire, payment app, and gift card — all gone the moment you send; ranking among them is splitting hairs. The real line is card vs. not-card: paying a stranger by app, wire, or gift card is like handing over cash.
This is the "move your money to a safe account" scam — a bank impersonation the FTC and CFPB document widely. Both tells are running: a rush (fraud on your account, act now) and a push (move the money yourself, right now). Caller ID is easily faked, and knowing the last four digits proves nothing — a real bank freezes a compromised account on its end; it never walks you through moving your own money, because the "new secure account" is the scammer’s. The move is the same one habit: hang up, and call the number on the back of the card. A strong answer leads with that, not with blame — the caller is good at this.
If someone’s been hit, there’s a clear path — share it, without the lecture. One: call the company where the fraud happened and have them freeze or close the account. Two: place a fraud alert or a credit freeze at the bureaus and pull your credit reports. Three: report it at IdentityTheft.gov for identity theft — it builds a step-by-step recovery plan — or ReportFraud.ftc.gov for a scam payment. If money went out by payment app or wire, call that company and bank right away; it’s a long shot, but speed is the only shot.
Don’t reply NO — replying tells a scammer the number is live and starts the script; and even a real alert doesn’t need your reply. Open your bank’s app, or call the number on the back of your card, and check from there. A strong answer names the rule: "I don’t act on the message that reached me; I reach the bank my own way."
Based on the Guide to credit scores.
michaelwestfinancials.com · © 2026 Michael West Financials · Education, not financial advice · Last reviewed July 2026